The news of Barry Keoghan being cast as Ringo Starr in Sam Mendes’ highly anticipated Beatles biopic series has elicited a range of emotions. On one hand, some fans are thrilled to see one of their favorite actors portraying the legendary drummer. Especially considering the impressive cast that includes Harris Dickinson as John Lennon, Paul Mescal as Paul McCartney, and Charlie Rowe as George Harrison. However, on the other hand, there are those who express reservations about the casting choices, particularly in the context of biopics. Many believe that the prevalent trend of casting highly attractive actors in biopics, often with a more attainable-looking haircut, detracts from the authenticity of the characters portrayed. In the case of the Beatles, who were known for their genuine, non-threatening boyish appeal, many feel that this approach undermines the essence of the group. While acknowledging that both Keoghan and Mescal are talented actors, some fans argue that the casting should have focused on finding actors who more closely resemble the real-life Beatles, both physically and in terms of their unique charisma.
This sentiment is further articulated by the author’s reference to Zadie Smith’s quote from her novel “On Beauty”: “Our memories are getting more beautiful and less real every day.” The author suggests that this quote reflects the prevalent Hollywood attitude towards biopic casting, prioritizing aesthetics over authenticity. The author acknowledges that there is a certain amount of suspension of disbelief required when watching biopics, but they question whether the casting of highly polished actors truly enhances the storytelling or whether it ultimately diminishes the connection between the audience and the characters they are supposed to represent.
It is important to note that this article was originally published on British Vogue, which may have influenced the author’s perspective on the casting decisions. Nonetheless, the article raises valid concerns about the impact of casting choices on the authenticity and emotional impact of biopics, particularly when portraying iconic figures like the Beatles. It remains to be seen how Mendes will approach the casting and portrayal of the Beatles in his upcoming series, and whether he will prioritize aesthetics or authenticity, or perhaps find a balance between the two.
