A Galveston County magistrate judge has sparked controversy after being called out on social media by a police union upset with the high number of defendants released from jail.
Galveston Municipal Police Association president Anthony Rogers criticized Magistrate Judge John Melcher, stating that he lacks sufficient criminal law experience. However, Judge Melcher dismissed the accusations, suggesting that Rogers’ dog may have comparable qualifications.
The union shared images of Melcher on social media, accusing him of allowing too many defendants to go free without paying bail. Rogers expressed concerns about the potential danger posed to the community and police officers.
Data shows that Galveston County has a significantly higher rate of defendants released without bail compared to other counties in Texas. In Galveston County, 34% of cases resulted in no bail being required, compared to 11% in Fort Bend County and 14% in Montgomery County.
Rogers highlighted a recent drug bust where the district attorney and sheriff’s office recommended a $550,000 bond, but Judge Melcher set it at less than $100,000. Rogers believes these decisions jeopardize public safety and hinder police efforts.
In response, Judge Melcher explained that he considers various factors when setting bail, including the risk of reoffending and the need for supervision. He pointed to the county’s supervised release program, which has shown positive results in terms of compliance and reducing recidivism among non-violent offenders.
Melcher expressed willingness to meet with the union to discuss concerns, but the union declined, preferring to address the issue with County Judge Mark Herman. Melcher urged the union to engage in direct dialogue rather than resorting to social media attacks.
