Popcorn GST Controversy: A Simple Tax Gets Complex?
The recent debate surrounding the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on popcorn has sparked a wider conversation about the complexity of India’s tax system. The controversy began when it was revealed that popcorn is taxed differently based on its ingredients and packaging – plain popcorn, ready-to-eat popcorn, and caramelized popcorn each fall under different GST slabs. This led to a flurry of social media memes and criticism.
Congress Leader Raises Concerns
Congress leader Jairam Ramesh has criticized the current GST structure, arguing that its complexity contradicts the promise of a ‘Good and Simple Tax’. He pointed out the absurdity of the three different tax slabs for popcorn as an example of this inherent complexity. Ramesh’s post on X highlighted the issue of GST evasion, fraud, and the number of bogus companies exploiting loopholes within the system. He also questioned the government’s preparedness for potential improvements and updates to the GST system.
GST Evasion and Loopholes
The concern over GST evasion is significant. Ramesh stated that the input tax credit fraud is frequent and thousands of bogus companies are designed to avoid paying taxes under GST system. He further mentioned that supply chain tracking is weak and the registration process is flawed, creating opportunities for exploitation. He cites recent data from the Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI) revealing ₹2.01 lakh crore in GST evasion during FY24, emphasizing the magnitude of the problem.
Finance Minister’s Response
Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman responded to the criticism by explaining the different tax rates for popcorn based on its composition. She clarified that the variation in GST rates stems from the different ingredients that change the product’s classification and thus, its taxation. Plain salted popcorn may be different tax than the ready-to-eat, pre-packaged variety and yet another if it’s caramelised with added sugar which changes the product category from namkeen to a confectionery, hence attracting a higher tax slab.
Kerala Congress’s Reaction
The Kerala unit of the Congress has mocked the government’s explanation. They highlighted the perceived illogical nature of the different tax rates, drawing parallels with other sweet products that might be subject to similar discrepancies in future.
A Call for GST 2.0?
Amidst the criticism, the call for a GST 2.0 is gaining traction. The current system’s complexity and the increasing instances of tax evasion are leading to demands for a complete overhaul to simplify the GST system and improve tax compliance. With the Union Budget just around the corner, there is increased pressure on the government to address these concerns and introduce substantial reforms to the GST system. The success of any such overhaul would depend on its ability to simplify processes, address loopholes, and improve monitoring to reduce tax evasion and create a truly ‘simple’ tax system.
Looking Ahead
The popcorn GST controversy serves as a microcosm of broader concerns surrounding the complexity of India’s taxation system. The need to balance revenue generation with ease of compliance remains a crucial challenge for the government as it moves toward a more robust and efficient tax regime. The coming Union Budget will likely be crucial in determining whether the government will respond to these concerns and pursue significant reforms in the GST system.