The eternal debate between these two bagel powerhouses has finally been settled! After a rigorous taste test, we have our winner: New York. While Montreal bagels have a distinct charm, their smaller size and sweeter flavor couldn’t compete with the generous raisins in New York’s cinnamon raisin bagels and the audacious flavors of their everything bagels. New York also takes the crown for the best bagel on its own and, most importantly, the best bagel sandwich. Don’t get us wrong, Montreal bagels are still incredible in their own right, but for the ultimate bagel experience, New York reigns supreme.