During Wednesday’s Supreme Court hearing on Idaho’s abortion restrictions, Joshua Turner, representing the state, faced criticism from the female justices for his condescending and evasive responses. Justice Amy Coney Barrett expressed irritation at Turner’s refusal to acknowledge that Idaho’s law criminalizes abortion as stabilizing treatment, which EMTALA mandates. Turner’s inconsistencies and reluctance to provide clear answers raised concerns about the state’s prosecutorial discretion, potentially endangering doctors who provide essential care. The gender divide was evident as the male justices showed little reaction to Turner’s dismissive attitude, highlighting the different perspectives on women’s health and reproductive rights.