PEN America has called off its annual awards ceremony due to widespread dissatisfaction with the organization’s response to the Israel-Hamas war. Dozens of nominees have dropped out of the event, including nine of the 10 Jean Stein Award finalists, citing concerns about alleged bias in favor of Israel and the downplaying of atrocities against Palestinian writers. PEN America has defended its work, citing its condemnation of the loss of life in Gaza and its efforts to support Palestinian writers. However, critics argue that these efforts are insufficient and call for the resignation of top officials.