Despite his eminent qualifications, Randy Mastro’s nomination as corporation counsel faces opposition from the City Council based solely on his association with Rudy Giuliani. The objection stems from Mastro’s representation of clients perceived as dubious, which is ironic considering the history of other city officials representing controversial entities. This selective outrage highlights a double standard that undermines the principle of legal representation for all citizens. Mastro’s reputation as a respected public servant and his commitment to pro bono work underscore his suitability for the role.